The Second Season: Winning Post-Holiday Consumers

• Author:

Couple looking at credit card statements after holiday shopping

Most holiday marketing campaigns end once the gifts are unwrapped, and the celebrations have ceased. But for financial institutions offering payment cards, the season technically continues into January. That’s when consumers open their statements, add up what they owe, and resolve to do better with money. How FIs show up in that moment can earn, or cost, long-term loyalty. 

With holiday campaigns already in market, now is the time to plan for what comes next. Below, we look at what the data shows about post-holiday consumers and outline four plays FI marketers can put in place for Q1. 

Forecast Signals

The size of the coming season sets the scale of the Q1 opportunity. Deloitte’s 2026 holiday retail forecast points to strong growth over a season that runs through January. Some key points include:  

  • Total sales are forecast at $1.70 trillion to $1.71 trillion for November 2026 through January 2027, up 4.0% to 4.8% over 2025  
  • E-commerce is forecast at $316.1 billion to $318.9 billion, up 7.5% to 8.4%  
  • Disposable personal income is projected to grow 4.5% to 5.2% during the season  

Deloitte also sees “value-seeking behaviors across income levels, including switching among brands and retailers and using promotions to manage spending.” These behaviors are expected to shape how consumers approach holiday shopping this season.  

For FIs, a bigger and more digital season means bigger January balances and a wave of new card-on-file and wallet credentials to activate. It also means value-focused messaging will matter to every segment.  

The Q1 Window is Short

Rising balances are only half the story. Timing matters just as much, because consumers focus on paydown for only a short stretch each year.  

In Q1 of 2026, the New York Fed reported that credit card balances fell by $25 billion to $1.25 trillion, a seasonal decline as consumers paid down holiday spending. However, the paydown didn’t last. By Q2, balances rose by $21 billion to $1.26 trillion. 

FIs should also consider who will be paying down balances in January and how much they owe. LendingTree’s holiday debt survey, fielded in December 2025, found that 37% took on holiday debt, averaging $1,223. Among those who borrowed, 62% used credit cards, 35% used BNPL loans, and 32% used store cards.  

Holiday debt isn’t limited to stretched households. In fact, LendingTree found six-figure earners (47%) were among the most likely to borrow. BNPL plans added to the strain. LendingTree’s 2026 BNPL report found more late payments and more users carrying three or more BNPL loans at once. 

Together, these numbers confirm a narrow campaign window. Consumers focus on paying down holiday balances in the first months of the year, then spending resumes. In our view, FIs that offer help during that window earn attention and goodwill; those that wait until spring risk missing the moment. And for customers juggling multiple BNPL plans, FIs have a clear opening: one simpler payment. 

Four Plays for a Winning Q1 

Based on these trends, Media Logic recommends four ways FIs can meet post-holiday consumers where they are: 

1. Lead with payoff support 

For consumers carrying holiday balances, helping with payoff is the most valuable thing an FI can offer. Options include balance transfer and consolidation offers for qualified customers, installment conversion for large purchases, and payoff trackers in the app. 

For customers juggling multiple BNPL plans, you’ll want to position your card or personal loan as one simpler payment. Proactive payment reminders tied to statement dates help customers avoid late fees and build goodwill. Keep the tone supportive and the terms clear. A cardholder who feels helped in January is more likely to keep that card at the front of their wallet in December. 

2. Turn rewards into a retention lever 

Payoff support helps customers who are stretched, and rewards give FIs a way to engage everyone else. PayPal’s 2026 Holiday Shopping Survey found 55 

Cardholders who don’t redeem during the holidays start the year with rewards they can put to work. A January campaign such as “apply your rewards to your holiday balance” delivers immediate value. It also reminds cardholders what they’d give up by switching cards, which makes redemption a retention tool as well as an engagement tool. 

3. Help resolutions stick, especially for stretched households 

In our experience, follow-through is where most resolutions stall, so sell the help rather than the product. Automated savings, roundups, goal-setting tools and credit score monitoring all make it easier to keep a resolution. 

Messaging that celebrates small, achievable steps, such as “start with $10 a week,” makes a fresh start feel within reach for households that can’t set aside much. 

4. Activate holiday acquisitions 

Deloitte’s forecast of strong e-commerce growth points to a wave of new card-on-file credentials, digital wallet users and, for many issuers, new cardholders. Acquisition alone doesn’t build a relationship, though. In our experience, the first 90 days set the pattern for long-term usage. A Q1 onboarding sequence that includes activation, wallet provisioning, autopay setup and a first-use incentive helps turn a holiday sign-up into a primary relationship. 

Timing and Channels 

A strong Q1 strategy depends on reaching customers at the right moment. Practical timing considerations include:  

  • Be in market by late December, but continue marketing through January, given attention span in December will be limited. Through messaging consistently, consumers will have seen the campaign multiple times and be familiar with it, encouraging action.  
  • Let data trigger the message. Send customers with high revolving balances payoff support, customers with large rewards balances redemption reminders, and new accounts with seasonal onboarding promotions such as an introductory balance transfer or cashback option when opening an account. 
  • Integrate mail and digital. Direct mail gives payoff and savings offers room to explain terms clearly. Add a USPS Informed Delivery ride-along image to each drop, then follow up with email, push and in-app messages timed to statement cycles, so the offer stays in front of customers across every channel. 

FIs that plan for the “second season” now, with payoff support, rewards redemption, savings resets and onboarding, will be well positioned to turn holiday spending into lasting relationships. 

Do you have additional questions or need a second set of eyes on your brand’s Q1 plan?  Contact Nicole Johnson, Group Director and Financial Services Practice Lead today.  

See Related Stories

“Coupon Book” Card Marketing

“Coupon Book” Card Marketing

Although Gen Zers are responsive to premium cards, various earning reports indicate that that they are also value-focused and eager to "do the math." To help justify steep annual fees, portfolio managers have focused on encouraging premium cardholders to take advantage of a barrage of statement credits, now often referred to as the new "coupon book."