Improving acquisition results through testing and refinement.

One key tactic to improve direct marketing response is continuous testing and refinement. When Bread Financial launched two new AAA Visa Cards in market, we first developed the initial direct marketing materials. But it didn’t stop there. Bread then asked us to help with the development of test creative for their pre-screened acquisition direct mail and email.

Each quarter, we updated the creative to test different components, while also maintaining the integrity of the control. The results of these tests have helped to continuously refine the offers and creative to maximize their effectiveness.

Bread Financial AAA email with Pre-Approved messaging AAA letter and envelope withe Pre-Approved messaging

We tested a different headline focus, shifting from branded to pre-approved messaging to more quickly communicate the low hurdle for prospects.

AAA email with Pre-Approved headline for the AAA Travel Advantage Visa Signature Credit Card
AAA email with limited time offer: Earn a $200 statement credit AAA email with headline featuring up to 5% cash back on AAA Daily Advantage Visa Signature Credit Card

We tested more headlines, as well as various limited-time only offers.

Two AAA letters with Pre-Approved messaging for both AAA Visa credit cards
3 different AAA statement inserts all with differentiating graphics and headlines promoting the Visa Daily and Travel Credit Cards

The test creatives were applied to both single and dual-product communications.

Ready to find your edge?

Get smarter strategy and breakthrough creative. Backed by unmatched client support.

Contact Us Today

See our latest posts.

Trends in Credit Card Acquisition

Trends in Credit Card Acquisition

Behind the credit card growth are strategies ranging from the tried and true to emerging trends in successfully acquiring cardholders and attracting new audiences.

Pay Later, Budget Now: How BNPL Is Reshaping Everyday Consumer Finance 

Pay Later, Budget Now: How BNPL Is Reshaping Everyday Consumer Finance 

Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) is no longer a novelty reserved for sneaker drops and flat-screen TVs. It has quietly become a household budgeting tool, woven into how consumers pay for groceries, utility bills, subscription services, and travel. That shift has profound implications for banks, credit unions, payment issuers, and fintechs — not just in product strategy, but in how marketing teams attract, retain, and engage customers.

Financial Services Ads Take the Field at Super Bowl LX

Financial Services Ads Take the Field at Super Bowl LX

Super Bowl LX drew 125M+ viewers and record-breaking ad prices, with financial services brands going big. The dominant theme was "AI is the new crypto", while others leaned on humor and humanity. Our takeaway: the strongest ads paired entertainment with a clear product message.